Peer Review Process

Review Process

The review process of the Refinery Journal involves several parties, including authors, editors, section editors, and reviewers. To ensure objectivity and maintain confidentiality throughout the evaluation process, the journal implements a Double-Blind Peer Review system, in which the identities of both authors and reviewers are kept anonymous.

Each manuscript submitted to the journal undergoes an initial screening by the editor. At this stage, the editor evaluates whether the manuscript aligns with the journal's focus and scope, particularly in areas related to oil refining, refinery operations, petroleum processing, process optimization, refinery technology, and the development of the downstream oil and gas industry. The manuscript is also assessed for compliance with the journal's author guidelines and formatting requirements.

Manuscripts that meet the initial screening criteria will be forwarded to qualified reviewers for further evaluation, focusing on the scientific quality, originality, relevance, methodology, and contribution of the research to the refinery industry. Meanwhile, manuscripts that do not fulfill the required criteria will be returned to the authors for revision or rejected by the editor.

Each manuscript is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers, with the review process generally taking approximately one to two weeks. The assessment is conducted based on established evaluation criteria provided in the journal's Reviewer Assessment Form. The overall publication process, from manuscript submission to publication, is estimated to take approximately eight weeks, depending on the review outcomes and the time required for revisions.